Scottish Field
RSS
The Real John Macnab

The challenge of many a huntsman

The expression ‘John Macnab’ is well known in the world of Scottish field sports especially at this time of the year.

It is used when someone manages in one day to kill a red deer stag, catch a salmon and shoot a brace of grouse – although wild goats and trout and other ‘achievements’ of a less notable nature are often substituted.

However exciting these may be for today’s participants they are a pale imitation of the original plot first enacted in Inverness-shire more than a century ago which became the source of the best known of all Highland deer stalking and salmon fishing novels.

It all began at a dinner held in Inverness in the summer of 1897 by the officers of the Militia Battalion of The Queen’s Own Cameron Highlanders when one of the company, Lt James Brander-Dunbar of Pitgaveny, near Elgin, announced, somewhat provocatively, that as he had not been invited to stalk anywhere that year he would be reduced to poaching and laid a £20 bet that he could kill a stag undetected on any forest in Scotland. A fellow officer, Captain James, 4th Lord Abinger, owner of the 80,000 acre Inverlochy Castle Estate near Fort William, immediately took up the challenge.

James Brander-Dunbar was no ordinary mortal. Born in 1875 he became a legend in his own long lifetime (he died in 1969 aged 94) as a traveller, soldier, forester, sportsman and laird and, of particular relevance to the tale of ‘John Macnab’, an inveterate deer poacher. For his foray into Lochaber he enlisted the help of Col William MacDonald, another brother officer whose family owned the famous ‘Dew of Ben Nevis’ whisky distillery but, more important, lived at Keppoch House near Spean Bridge on the very boundary of Lord Abinger’s estate.

Brander-Dunbar’s escapade almost failed before it began when Lady Middleton, wife

SEE OCTOBER EDITION OF SCOTTISH FIELD TO READ FULL STORY


  • Contact US
  • Scottish Calendars
  • Xmas Gift Idea
  • Click here to view sample of Scottish Field (PDF)
  • Click here to view some of Scotland's premier property
  • Scottish Field. Click here for  links to other websites
E-mail Updates
Online Poll

Donald Trump has unveiled his ambitious plans for a golf Mecca in the north-east of Scotland. These new golf destinations may be welcomed by the tourism industry, but are they good news for the Scottish game and the country as a whole?

  • Yes - It will provide better facilities on which to practice and bring more money into the game which, in turn, will raise the standard of player produced by Scotland.
  • Yes - The areas involved will benefit greatly due to the jobs the projects create.
  • No - Exclusive golf resorts do not meet the needs of the average golfer - they just pander to wealthy foreign tourists.
  • No - The local environment will suffer as a result of all the construction work, roads etc. which will have to be built.
  • Undecided - Need more information
Copyright 2006 Scottish Field & The Oban Times Group all rights reserved
No part of this publication may be reproduced without the express written permission of the publishers.
Email the editor Email the Advertising department Email the subscriptions department



Powered by WebRing.
Email Webmaster